Sell Your Jewelry

Looking for the best place to sell your jewelry in Columbus, Ohio? Come visit Seth in Old Worthington for an honest evaluation, top prices, and immediate payment.

Do you have jewelry gathering dust in your drawer or safety deposit box? Have you inherited a collection that you’ll never wear (and your kids don’t want)? Perhaps you received a gift that doesn’t suit your taste, or moved on from a painful relationship? Or maybe you just want to free up some cash?

No matter the reason, you deserve the best price when you sell your jewelry, and that’s why it’s important to work with an experienced professional who has your interests at heart.

Seth has handled thousands of pieces of jewelry, and provides honest evaluations, the best possible offers, premium prices for signed pieces, and immediate payment for the items you wish to sell.

Expert Evaluations: Get the fair value for your items
Local Presence: Come meet Seth in person
Free No-Obligation Offers: The choices is always yours
Instant Payments: Or within 24 hours if shipped
Price Match Guarantee: We’ll match any competitor’s price
Satisfaction Guaranteed: Or we’ll return your items free

Fill out the form to get your FREE valuation

Ohio’s #1 jewelry Buyer

Price Match Guarantee

FREE and Insured FedEx Shipping

100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

BBB Accredited Business

I sent my information and a few photos and heard back from Seth that same night! He gave me a general estimate and I later made an appointment so he could assess in person. Seth was so warm and friendly! The whole experience was great and I felt like I made a new friend by the time I walked out.

Carol Stokes

Seth was an absolute pleasure to work with! He made selling my diamond ring easy, simple and fun. He was so kind, professional, timely, and communicated efficiently. He made the whole experience enjoyable. I will most certainly be recommending Seth for selling or buying jewelry to everyone.

Jessica Levy

Seth was great to work with. He is very personable and treated us as family. We will definitely be returning for any future needs! We have been telling everyone we know about him since our meeting. Thanks Seth!

Emily Clark

Great guy! Easy to do business with. Highly recommend selling jewelry to Seth.

Suzanne Meade

I needed to sell a diamond solitaire ring, and Seth was able to pay more than two other offers I got locally. The process was surprisingly relaxing and easy. He also helped me find an affordable pair of diamond studs. I have already recommended Seth to a few colleagues and friends.

Lainey Stanley

This guy is the real deal! He’s so diligent in responding and very knowledgeable along with teaching you about your jewelry, which I appreciate greatly. Message him with questions!

Katy Satterthwaite

It was a pleasure to work with Seth! I found him on Facebook, read his information and decided to make an appointment to sell my mothers estate jewelry. He responded promptly, and was very diligent and courteous in examining all the pieces. He made quite a generous offer! Seth was very friendly and honest to work with. A great experience!

Jeanne Q.

Meet Seth, Ohio’s Leading jewelry Expert

Born and raised in Plain City, Ohio, Seth’s jewelry and watch expertise has taken him around the world with clients in Asia, Europe, South America, and the Middle East, culminating in the founding of one of the world’s foremost jewelry and watch auction houses.

He is recognized as a leading expert in the secondhand jewelry and watch markets and has been featured by major media and invited to present at prestigious events, from appraisal conventions to GIA alumni meetings.

In his business and travels, Seth has had the opportunity to handle tens of thousands of pieces of jewelry and watches, including some of the rarest, most exquisite, and most iconic pieces, collections, and estates—from Art Deco tiaras, to large colored diamonds; from signed French jewels, to European royal collections; from “Paul Newman” Rolexes, to the highly sought-after Cartier Crash.

He is a member of the Jewelers Vigilance Committee, Jewelers of America, and is a BBB Accredited Business.

Seth Has Been Featured In…

How It Works

Working with Seth is quick and easy. It’s just 3 simple steps.

1. Send Photos & Descriptions

Text, submit, or email photos, descriptions, certificates, receipts and any other info you have about your jewelry to get a valuation range.

2. Meet or Ship Your Items

Show your jewelry to Seth in person, either at his office in Old Worthington or your home/office/bank vault, OR ship them for FREE via FedEx.

3. Get Your Valuation & Offer

Once Seth has inspected your items, you will receive a FREE market valuation and a zero obligation offer. If you’d like to sell, Seth will write you a check on the spot.

Book an Appointment Ship My Items

Types of Jewelry Seth Buys in Columbus, Ohio

Seth buys all types of fine jewelry ranging from simple engagement rings to rare antique estates. He pays premium prices for period and contemporary pieces by famous design houses such as David Webb, Cartier, Tiffany, Van Cleef & Arpels, Harry Winston, and more.

Here are just some of the items Seth buys in Columbus:

Rings, necklaces, pendants, charms, bracelets/anklets, earrings, cufflinks, watches, brooches/pins.
Fine, vintage, antique, and estate jewelry made with precious metals (gold, silver, and platinum).
Fine and vintage watches, such as Rolex and Cartier.
Diamonds and precious gemstones, such as rubies and sapphires.

Your jewelry can be old or new, broken, scratched, and mismatched—Seth buys it all.